IELTS Writing Task 2 · Discussion Essay · Government & Crime

CCTV cameras are everywhere now, in train stations, shopping malls, even quiet residential streets. Supporters say they stop crime before it happens. Critics say we are trading away our privacy without really thinking it through. Both sides have a point, which is exactly what makes this a tricky Task 2 question. Here is how a Band 7 and a Band 9 response each handle it.
Essay Question
Some people believe that the widespread use of CCTV cameras in public places is necessary to prevent crime, while others believe it is an invasion of personal privacy. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 7 Sample Answer
In many cities around the world, CCTV cameras are installed in public places like streets and shopping centres. Some people think these cameras are important to stop crime, while others believe they invade people’s privacy. This essay will look at both views before giving my opinion.
On one hand, people who support CCTV cameras say they help reduce crime. When criminals know they are being watched, they may be less likely to steal or hurt someone. Also, if a crime does happen, the police can use the camera footage to find and catch the criminal more easily. This makes public places feel safer for everyone. In busy railway stations, for example, cameras often help officers find a missing child or a stolen bag quickly.
On the other hand, some people think CCTV cameras are a problem because they watch people all the time, even when they are not doing anything wrong. They feel that this is an invasion of their privacy because someone might be watching them without their permission. Some people also worry about who has access to this footage and how it might be used.
In my opinion, I believe CCTV cameras are useful because they help make public places safer and help catch criminals. However, I think there should be clear rules about who can watch the footage and how long it is kept, so that people’s privacy is still respected.
In conclusion, while CCTV cameras can invade privacy, I think their benefits for public safety are more important, as long as there are proper rules to protect people’s personal information.
(264 words)
Band 9 Sample Answer
The proliferation of CCTV surveillance in public spaces has become a contentious issue, with advocates emphasising its crime-prevention benefits while critics decry its encroachment on personal privacy. This essay will examine both perspectives before presenting my own view.
Supporters of widespread CCTV deployment contend that visible surveillance exerts a powerful deterrent effect on potential offenders, who are less inclined to commit crimes when aware of being monitored. Moreover, recorded footage provides law enforcement with invaluable evidence for identifying and prosecuting perpetrators after an incident occurs, thereby enhancing overall public safety and community confidence in shared spaces. For a woman walking home late at night, for example, knowing that cameras cover the route can make a real difference to her sense of security.
Conversely, opponents argue that constant surveillance constitutes an unwarranted intrusion into the daily lives of ordinary, law-abiding citizens who have done nothing to warrant such scrutiny. This persistent observation, they contend, erodes the fundamental expectation of anonymity in public spaces and raises troubling questions about who controls this footage, how securely it is stored, and whether it could be misused for purposes beyond its original intent.
Weighing both perspectives, I believe the security benefits of CCTV generally outweigh the privacy concerns, provided that robust safeguards are implemented. Specifically, governments should establish transparent policies governing data retention periods, restrict footage access to authorised personnel, and subject surveillance systems to independent regulatory oversight.
In conclusion, although CCTV surveillance inevitably raises legitimate privacy concerns, its demonstrable contribution to public safety justifies its continued use, provided it is accompanied by stringent accountability measures.
(261 words)
Why the Band 9 Answer Scores Higher
| Criterion | Band 7 | Band 9 |
|---|---|---|
| Task Response | States both sides simply | Explains the deterrent mechanism and proposes specific safeguards |
| Coherence & Cohesion | Basic linkers (“On one hand”, “On the other hand”) | Varied markers (“Supporters contend”, “Conversely”, “Weighing both perspectives”) |
| Lexical Resource | General phrasing (“stop crime”, “invade privacy”) | Precise vocabulary (“crime-prevention benefits”, “encroachment”, “regulatory oversight”) |
| Grammatical Range | Mostly simple/compound sentences | Relative clauses, varied complex sentence structures |
Test Your Own Writing
Want to see where your essay would land? Try this exact prompt on our free Writing Task 2 test and get a full band-score breakdown in minutes.