The Government Should Spend Money Preserving Historic Buildings Rather Than New Housing Or Facilities — IELTS Writing Task 2

IELTS Writing Task 2 · Opinion Essay · Culture, Media & Family

Should governments preserve historic buildings or build new housing? IELTS Writing Task 2 opinion essay

An old building full of history on one side, a housing shortage on the other — which one should get the government’s money? It is a tension that comes up in real cities all the time, and IELTS has turned it into a solid Task 2 opinion question. Here is how a Band 7 and a Band 9 response each argue their side.

Essay Question

Some people believe that governments should spend money preserving old, historic buildings rather than using the funds to construct new housing or modern facilities. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 7 Sample Answer

I partly agree that governments should spend money on preserving historic buildings, but I do not think this should always come before building new housing.

Firstly, old buildings are part of a country’s history and culture. If they are destroyed, future generations will never be able to see them or learn from them. Tourists also visit countries because of their historic sites, so preserving them can bring in money through tourism. For example, cities like Rome and Paris earn a lot from visitors who come to see old buildings.

However, many countries also have a serious shortage of housing. People need safe and affordable homes, and if the government spends too much money on old buildings, there may not be enough left for new housing projects. In cities with large populations, this is a very urgent problem that affects ordinary people’s daily lives. A family living in a crowded rented room, for instance, would probably prefer a new flat to a restored old palace.

Therefore, I believe the government should try to balance both needs. Not every old building needs to be preserved; only the most historically important ones should receive funding. The rest of the budget can be used for new housing and modern facilities, which are needed by the current population. One practical solution is to fund the oldest and most important sites first and to ask private companies to help with the rest.

In conclusion, while preserving important historic buildings is valuable, it should not be the only priority. Governments must also provide enough housing for their citizens.

(261 words)

Band 9 Sample Answer

The question of whether to prioritise architectural heritage over new housing exposes a genuine tension between a nation’s cultural memory and its citizens’ present-day welfare. In my view, this is not a binary choice, and a sensible government should pursue a carefully calibrated allocation of funds rather than committing wholesale to either option.

Proponents rightly emphasise that historic buildings constitute tangible links to a nation’s cultural identity, offering insights into craftsmanship, social history, and civic values that textbooks cannot replicate. Beyond their intrinsic worth, such structures frequently underpin lucrative tourism industries; cities like Kyoto and Florence derive substantial revenue from visitors drawn specifically to their preserved architecture, revenue that can, in turn, be reinvested into broader public services, including housing.

Nevertheless, this argument cannot be allowed to eclipse the acute housing shortages afflicting many urban centres. When families are forced into overcrowded or unaffordable accommodation, the opportunity cost of channelling scarce public funds into preservation projects becomes difficult to justify on purely moral grounds. Consequently, diverting disproportionate funding towards buildings rather than people risks exacerbating pressing social problems, including homelessness and spiralling rental costs.

Given these competing imperatives, I would argue for a criteria-based approach: structures of exceptional historical or architectural significance warrant protection, while less distinguished properties might reasonably be repurposed or redeveloped to accommodate housing needs. This selective strategy allows governments to safeguard cultural heritage without neglecting the urgent, tangible needs of their populations.

In conclusion, heritage preservation and housing development need not be mutually exclusive; thoughtful, selective policy-making can accommodate both, ensuring neither cultural continuity nor public welfare is unduly sacrificed.

(264 words)

Why the Band 9 Answer Scores Higher

Criterion Band 7 Band 9
Task Response States a partial agreement with relevant ideas, but development stays general and examples are brief. Directly engages with the tension in the question and proposes a clear, reasoned criteria-based position rather than a vague middle ground.
Coherence & Cohesion Uses basic linkers (Firstly, However, Therefore) that work but feel mechanical. Builds a sophisticated argument chain (Proponents rightly emphasise / Nevertheless / Consequently / Given these competing imperatives) that signals nuanced logical progression.
Lexical Resource Accurate but common vocabulary (serious shortage, affordable homes, historically important). Precise, less common collocations (tangible links to cultural identity, opportunity cost, spiralling rental costs, criteria-based approach) used naturally and accurately.
Grammatical Range Mostly simple and compound sentences with correct but limited structures. Wide range of complex structures (cleft sentences, non-finite clauses, conditional reasoning) handled with full control and no errors.

Attempt This Question

Want to measure your own writing against these samples? Try this question on our free Writing Task 2 test and get instant, detailed feedback.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top